Activists slam Michelle Bachelet’s six-day visit for whitewashing repression against Uyghurs, Tibetans, Southern Mongolians, Hong Kongers and others
8 June 2022
We, 230 Uyghur, Tibetan, Southern Mongolian, Hong Kong, and Chinese democracy and international human rights advocacy groups, call for the immediate resignation of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights after she whitewashed the Chinese government’s human rights atrocities during her recent visit to China. We further call on the UN Secretary General to not propose the renewal of her mandate [1] and demand the High Commissioner immediately release the report on the human rights violations against Uyghurs and other Turkic communities in East Turkistan [Ch: Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region].
During her six-day visit to China, the first by a High Commissioner since 2005, Michelle Bachelet squandered a rare opportunity to promote accountability by failing to address the litany of systematic human rights violations committed by the Chinese authorities. This includes genocide and crimes against humanity in East Turkistan. Bachelet also neglected to offer a single specific recommendation to address the gravity of the human rights crisis [2]. This abject failure to hold the Chinese government accountable for its crimes comes despite an unprecedented call in June 2020, by over 50 UN experts for “decisive measures” to protect fundamental freedoms in China [3].
The High Commissioner legitimized Beijing’s attempt to cover up its crimes by using the Chinese government’s false “counter-terrorism” framing [4] and repeatedly referred to the notorious internment camps by the Chinese government’s term: “Vocational Education and Training Centers” (VETCs). Just days prior, the ‘Xinjiang Police Files’ revealed further incriminating evidence of the mass internment of thousands of Uyghurs and Directives from Beijing to treat detainees like dangerous criminals and to open fire to stop escapees [5]. While world leaders responded by calling for an immediate investigation, Bachelet remained silent. Since 2021, the High Commissioner has also stalled on the commitment to release a report on the human rights violations against Uyghurs and other Turkic communities in East Turkistan. The repeated, open-ended, and unexplained delays call into serious question the credibility of her Office to fulfil its mandate.
During her four year tenure, Bachelet has been entirely silent on the human rights crisis enveloping Tibet and failed to even request access to the occupied country despite no High Commissioner visiting since 1998. She did not visit Tibet on this trip, and when she finally mentioned Tibet during her end-of-visit press conference it was brief and in general terms, failing to take the rare opportunity to critique and address the unprecedented, systematic and escalating attacks taking place on Tibetan language and identity today [6]. She also referred only to the “Tibet Autonomous Region,” – what China refers to as Tibet – ignoring the Tibetan autonomous prefectures and counties in Sichuan, Qinghai, Gansu, and Yunnan that make up half of Tibet and are home to more than half of the total Tibetan population [7].
Moreover, the High Commissioner did not visit Hong Kong and failed to condemn the Chinese government’s unrelenting campaign to destroy human rights and democracy in the city, which had escalated since the most recent mass protests broke out in 2019. In her end-of-visit statement, she grossly underplayed the crackdown, calling the arbitrary detention and incarceration of over 1,000 political prisoners under the National Security Law and other alleged crimes only as “deeply worrying”[8]. This is yet another sign of her inexplicable unwillingness to confront Chinese leaders over well-documented and egregious abuses of human rights.
The High Commissioner also made no mention of Southern Mongolia (Ch: Inner Mongolia), despite Chinese authorities engaging in a far-reaching assault on Mongolian identity and the unprecedented mass protests across Southern Mongolia in 2020. No reference was made to China’s so-called “bilingual” education program which recently replaced Mongolian with Chinese as the language of instruction in all elementary and middle schools nor to all the Mongolian herders who have been targeted for fighting policies that are destroying their traditional livelihoods, including China’s illegal land confiscations.
The High Commissioner has wasted a much needed opportunity to meet with top Chinese leaders as she shied away from publicly raising and condemning the widespread torture, enforced disappearance, arbitrary detention, organ harvesting, and routine persecution of faith communities. Instead, Bachelet lauded the Chinese authorities for making what she called “important legislative and judicial reforms” as well as “improvements for protection of women’s rights.”
Bachelet also naively posed for a photo opportunity with Chinese Minister of Foreign Affairs, Wang Yi, who presented her with a book of Xi’s quotations on “human rights”. She furthermore gave praise to China’s commitment to multilateralism, despite widespread evidence that Beijing has routinely sought to silence criticism of its human rights record before UN bodies and weaken UN institutions [9].
The High Commissioner’s end-of-visit statement, attempted to claw back some legitimacy by stating that she “met virtually with a number of civil society organisations.” In doing so, she failed to mention that this was the first time in four years that she agreed to meet with any affected communities despite consistent requests. By holding a two hour virtual meeting a matter of days before her visit, she limited the space and scope of any substantive discussions. The meeting invitation only came after 220 Tibetan, Uyghur, Hong Kong, Southern Mongolian, and Chinese democracy groups demanded the High Commissioner reverse her plans to visit China or risk walking into a propaganda minefield laid out by the Chinese Communist Party [10]; a that fear that has now been materialised.
The failed visit by the High Commissioner has not only worsened the human rights crisis of those living under the Chinese government’s rule, but also severely compromised the integrity of the Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights in promoting and protecting human rights globally. An independent, experienced and honest High Commissioner is crucial to ensure truth, justice, and reparations for crimes committed in violation of international law. Michelle Bachelet has repeatedly fallen short in her ability to uphold this vital mandate and it is under such reprehensible conditions that we are calling for her immediate resignation.
| Signed by: Act with HK Aide aux Refugies Tibetains Alaskans for Tibet Alberta Uyghur Association Amigos de Tibet Colombia Amigos del Tíbet Chile Amigos del Tibet El Salvador Anterrashtriya Bharat – Tibbet Sahyog Samiti Asociación Cultural Peruano Tibetana Asociación Cultural Tibetano Costarricense Association Cognizance Tibet Association Drôme Ardèche-Tibet Associazione Italia-Tibet Australia Tibet Council Australian Uyghur Association Australian Uyghur Tangritagh Women’s Association Bay Area Friends of Tibet Belgium Uyghur Association Bharrat Tibbat Samvad Manch, India Blue Crescent Humanitarian Aid Association Boston Tibet Network Briancon05 Urgence Tibet CADAL Campaign for Uyghurs Canada Tibet Committee Casa del Tibet Casa Tibet México Centro De Cultura Tibetana, Brazil Chi Milk Tea Alliance Chicago Solidarity with Hong Kong 芝援香港 China Against the Death Penalty China Aid Association Circle of Friends Citizen Power Initiatives for China Comite de Apoyo al Tibet Committee of 100 for Tibet Core Group for Tibetan Cause, India Czechs Support Tibet Dawn of Hong Kong DC4HK (Washingtonians Supporting Hong Kong) Dialogue China Dream for Children, Japan DUQ Ayallar komtiti Dutch Uyghur human rights foundation Dutch Uyghur Human Rights Foundation East Turkestan Press and Media Association East Turkestan Union in Europe East Turkestan Union of Muslim Scholars East Turkistan Association of Canada East Turkistan Education and Solidarity Association East Turkistan Entrepreneur Tradesmen and Industrialists Businessmen Association East Turkistan Human Rights Watch East Turkistan New Generation Movement East Turkistan New Generation Movement East Turkistan Nuzugum Culture and Family Association East Turkistan Sports and Development Association East Turkistan Union in Europe Eastern Turkistan Foundation EcoTibet Ireland European East Turkistan Education Association Finnish Uyghur Culture Centre Foundation for Universal Responsibility of the Dalai Lama France-Tibet Free Indo-Pacific Alliance Free Tibet Free Tibet Fukuoka Friends of Tibet Costa Rica Friends of Tibet in Finland Friends of Tibet New Zealand Furkan Education and Cooperation Association Grupo de Apoio ao Tibete, Portugal Hira Education Association Hoca Ahmet Yesevi Science and lore Foundation Hong Kong Collaborative Academic Network (HKCAN) Hong Kong Committee in Norway Hong Kong Democracy Council Hong Kong Forum, Los Angeles Hong Kong International Alliance Brisbane Hong Kong Liberation Coalition Hong Kong Professional Network Hong Kongers in San Francisco Bay Area Human Rights Network for Tibet and Taiwan Ilham Tohti Initiative Ili Meshrep Educational Foundation India Tibet Friendship Society Inner Mongolia People’s Party Institute of China Studies International Society of Human Rights, Munich International Tibet Network Secretariat International Tibet Independence Movement International Union of East Turkistan Organisations Isa Yusuf Alptekin Foundation Israeli Friends of the Tibetan People Japan Association of Monks for Tibet (Super Sangha) Japan Uyghur Association Justice For All Canada Justice for Uyghurs Knowledge and Service Solidarity and Cooperation Association Les Amis du Tibet Belgium Les Amis du Tibet Luxembourg Lions Des Neiges Mont Blanc, France Lungta Association Belgium Maison des Himalayas Maison du Tibet – Tibet Info McMaster Stands With Hong Kong National Campaign for Tibetan Support, India National Democratic Party of Tibet Norwegian Uyghur Committee Objectif Tibet Omer Uygur Foundation Passeport Tibetain Phagma Drolma-Arya Tara Public Association of Uyghurs “Ittipak” of the Kyrgyz Republic RangZen:Movimento Tibete Livre, Brazil Roof of the World Foundation, Indonesia Sakya Trinley Ling Santa Barbara Friends of Tibet Satuq Bugrakhan Foundation of Science and Civilization Save Tibet Foundation Save Tibet, Austria Shambhala Sangha Sierra Friends of Tibet Society for Threatened Peoples International Southern Mongolian Human Rights Information Center Stop Uyghur Genocide Students for a Free Tibet Students for a Free Tibet Canada Students for a Free Tibet Denmark Students for a Free Tibet France Students for a Free Tibet India Students for a Free Tibet Japan Students for a Free Tibet UK Support Hong Kong Independence Movement Svenska Uigur Union Sweden Uyghur Education Union Sweden Uyghur Union Swedish Tibet Committee Swiss Tibetan Friendship Association Taiwan Friends of Tibet Tashi Delek Bordeaux The Norwegian Tibet Committee The Youth Liberation Front of Tibet, Mongolia and Turkestan Tibet Action Group of Western Australia Tibet Action Institute Tibet cesky Tibet Committee of Fairbanks Tibet Group, Panama Tibet Initiative Deutschland Tibet Justice Center Tibet Lives, India Tibet Mx Tíbet Patria Libre, Uruguay Tibet Rescue Initiative in Africa Tibet Society Tibet Society of South Africa Tibet Solidarity Tibet Support Committee Denmark Tibet Support Group Adelaide Tibet Support Group Ireland Tibet Support Group Kenya Tibet Support Group Kiku, Japan Tibet Support Group Netherlands Tibetan Association of Germany Tibetan Association of Ithaca Tibetan Association of Northern California Tibetan Association of Philadelphia Tibetan Association of Washington DC Tibetan Community Austria Tibetan Community in Britain Tibetan Community in Denmark Tibetan Community in Ireland Tibetan Community of Italy Tibetan Community Queensland Tibetan Community Sweden Tibetan Community Victoria Tibetan Cultural Association Quebec Tibetan Programme of The Other Space Foundation Tibetan Women’s Association (Central) Tibetan Youth Association in Europe Tibetan Youth Congress Tibetans of Mixed Heritage Tibetisches Zentrum Hamburg TIBETmichigan TSG – Slovenia Turkish Welfare Association U.S. Tibet Committee Uighur Association Victoria Australia UK Uyghur Community UNFFT United Macedonian Diaspora University of Toronto Hong Kong Public Affairs and Social Service Society Unrepresented Nations and Peoples Organization US HongKongers Club Uyghur Academy Uyghur Academy Australia Uyghur Academy Canada Uyghur Academy Europe Uyghur Academy Foundation Uyghur Academy Japan Uyghur Academy USA Uyghur American Association Uyghur Association France Uyghur Association of Victoria, Australia Uyghur Association Switzerland Uyghur Center for Human Rights and Democracy Uyghur Community in Austria Uyghur Cultural and Education Union in Germany Uyghur Human Rights Project Uyghur Projects Foundation Uyghur Research Institute Uyghur Rights Advocacy Project Uyghur Science and Civilization Research Foundation Uyghur Science and Ingenuity Foundation Uyghur Transitional Justice Database Uyghur Youth Union in Kazakhstan Uyghurischer Verein Schweiz Uyghuristan Republican Party Uygur ilim – Meripet vakfi Uyhur medeniyet we maarip birliki , Germaniye Victims of Communism Memorial Foundation Victoria Uyghur Association Voces Tibet We The Hongkongers Western Australian Association for Pan-Asian Democracy Women of the World, teaming for Tibetans World League for Freedom and Democracy World Mongol Federation USA World Uyghur Congress World Uyghur Congress Foundation |
Editors Notes:
[1] “In accordance with General Assembly resolution 48/141, the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights is appointed by the Secretary-General of the United Nations and approved by the General Assembly, with due regard to geographical rotation for a fixed term of four years with a possibility of one renewal for another fixed term of four years.” https://documents-dds-ny.un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/N94/012/56/PDF/N9401256.pdf?OpenElement
[2] OHCHR, ‘ Statement by UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Michelle Bachelet after official visit to China’ 28 May 2022: https://www.ohchr.org/en/statements/2022/05/statement-un-high-commissioner-human-rights-michelle-bachelet-after-official
[3] OHCHR, ‘UN experts call for decisive measures to protect fundamental freedoms in China’ 26 June 2020: https://www.ohchr.org/en/press-releases/2020/06/un-experts-call-decisive-measures-protect-fundamental-freedoms-china?LangID=E&NewsID=26006
[4] OHCHR, ‘Expert: sustained detention is a “dark stain on our collective conscience”’ 27 April 2022: https://www.ohchr.org/en/stories/2022/04/expert-sustained-detention-dark-stain-our-collective-conscience ; OHCHR, https://spcommreports.ohchr.org/TMResultsBase/DownLoadPublicCommunicationFile?gId=24845
[5] BBC, ‘Xinjiang Police Files: Inside a Chinese internment camp’ 24 May 2022: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/resources/idt-8df450b3-5d6d-4ed8-bdcc-bd99137eadc3 ; https://www.xinjiangpolicefiles.org/
[6] For example, see Tibet Action Institute, “Separated From Their Families, Hidden From the World: China’s Vast System of Colonial Boarding Schools Inside Tibet,” 2021, pg. 24,
available at: https://s7712.pcdn.co/wp-content/uploads/2022/01/2021_ColonialBoardingSchoolReport_Digital.pdf
[7] ‘Tibet’ refers to the three Tibetan provinces of Amdo, Kham and U-Tsang. In the 1960s, the Chinese government split Tibet into new administrative divisions: the Tibetan Autonomous Region (TAR), and Tibetan Autonomous Prefectures within Qinghai, Gansu, Sichuan and Yunnan Provinces. When the Chinese government references Tibet, it is referring to the TAR.
[8] Hong Kong Democracy Council, “Hong Kong Reaches a Grim Milestone: 1,000 Political Prisoners,” 22 May 2022:
https://hkdc.us/political-prisoners-research-report/
[9] Human Rights Watch, ‘The Costs of International Advocacy: China’s Interference in United Nations Human Rights Mechanisms’ September 2017: https://www.hrw.org/report/2017/09/05/costs-international-advocacy/chinas-interference-united-nations-human-rights
[10] Tibet Advocacy Coalition, ‘Over 220 groups urgently demand UN High Commissioner immediately postpone her visit to China‘ 5 May 2022: https://tibetadvocacy.org/over-220-groups-urgently-demand-un-high-commissioner-immediately-postpone-her-visit-to-china/